Identifying Localization in Peer Reviews of Argument Diagrams
نویسندگان
چکیده
Peer-review systems such as SWoRD lack intelligence for detecting and responding to problems with students’ reviewing performance. While prior work has demonstrated the feasibility of automatically identifying desirable feedback features in free-text reviews of student papers, similar methods have not yet been developed for feedback regarding argument diagrams. One desirable feedback feature is problem localization, which has been shown to positively correlate with feedback implementation in both student papers and argument diagrams. In this paper we demonstrate that features previously developed for identifying localization in paper reviews do not work well when applied to peer reviews of argument diagrams. We develop a novel algorithm tailored for reviews of argument diagrams, and demonstrate significant performance improvements in identifying problem localization in an experimental evaluation.
منابع مشابه
Identifying Problem Localization in Peer-Review Feedback
In this paper, we use supervised machine learning to automatically identify the problem localization of peer-review feedback. Using five features extracted via Natural Language Processing techniques, the learned model significantly outperforms a standard baseline. Our work suggests that it is feasible for future tutoring systems to generate assessments regarding the use of localization in stude...
متن کاملClassroom Evaluation of a Scaffolding Intervention for Improving Peer Review Localization
A peer review system that automatically evaluates student feedback comments was deployed in a university research methods course. The course required students to create an argument diagram to justify a hypothesis, then use this diagram to write a paper introduction. Diagram and paper first drafts were both reviewed by peers. During peer review, the system automatically analyzed the quality of s...
متن کاملCosmological argument in proving the existence of God from Imam Khomeini's (RA) point of view
This article reviews Cosmological argument in proving the existence of God from the viewpoint of Imam Khomeini (RA). At first, various views to the existence of God are reviewed and then its etymology will be reviewed. Cosmological argument proves God through universal premises about truth and world and and the Movement Argument, Casual Argument and Necessity and Possibility Argument are dif...
متن کاملThe Effect of Argument Mapping Instruction on L2 Writing Achievement across Writing Tasks and Writing Components: A Case of Iranian EFL Learners
Argument maps as schematic representations of arguments and their logical and evidential relationships are effective diagrams for instruction in education as well as in L2 development. However, their use for teaching L2 writing in EFL contexts has not been adequately studied. Therefore, this study investigated the effect of argument mapping instruction on Iranian EFL learners’ writing achieveme...
متن کاملAuthor’s response to reviews Title: USER TESTING OF AN ADAPTATION OF FISHBONE DIAGRAMS TO DEPICT RESULTS OF SYSTEMATIC REVIEWS Authors:
Title: USER TESTING OF AN ADAPTATION OF FISHBONE DIAGRAMS TO DEPICT RESULTS OF SYSTEMATIC REVIEWS Authors: Gerald Gartlehner ([email protected]) Marie-Therese Schultes ([email protected]) Viktoria Titscher ([email protected]) Laura Morgan ([email protected]) Georgiy Bobashev ([email protected]) Peyton Williams ([email protected]) Suzanne ...
متن کامل